By Will Rietveld
I reviewed the Patagonia
Nano-Air Jacket a year ago and found the jacket’s active exertion comfort
range occurs at temperatures lower than I normally encounter. In other words,
it is more insulation than I need in my location for high exertion activities.
Granted, it is a very attractive, and warm, jacket for less active endeavors.
Still wanting to test the concept of “breathable insulation”, I opted to next test |
Here’s the stats: the Nano-Air Jacket has 60 ounces/square
yard polyester insulation, while the Nano-Air Light Hybrid Jacket has 40
ounces/square yard insulation, one-third less. The fabrics in the two jackets are very
similar.
The whole idea behind these jackets is to provide extended
range comfort and avoid overheating during aerobic outdoor cool weather
activities. So, how does the lighter weight Nano-Air Light Hybrid Jacket
perform in active exertion conditions?
Specifications and Features
Manufacturer
|
|
Model
|
Nano-Air Light Hybrid Jacket
|
Fabrics
|
Outer shell is 1.3 oz/sq yd nylon ripstop, lining is 2
oz/sq yd nylon plain weave, both with stretch and DWR
|
Breathability
|
Frontside fabric: 40 CFM, backside fabric 130 CFM
|
Insulation
|
40 oz/sq yd Full-Range polyester
|
Weight
|
Size men’s Large tested: measured weight 10.85 oz; mfr
specification 10.1 oz for size Medium
|
Features
|
Full-height front zipper, slim fit, stretch fabric,
wind-resistant frontside fabric, breathable backside fabric, 2 zippered
handwarmer pockets, elastic hem and cuffs, thumbloops
|
MSRP
|
$199
|
Description
The Patagonia Nano-Air Light Hybrid Jacket is designed to be
a high performance garment. Patagonia ’s
synthetic Full-Range polyester insulation is analogous to Polartec Alpha, which
is a “breathable insulation” meant to keep you comfortable during aerobic
activities in cool temperatures, and provide an extended comfort range.
Close up of the insulated frontside and knitted backside. |
Field Testing and Performance
I tested the jacket on 20 outings consisting of day hiking,
snowshoeing, cross-country skiing, backcountry skiing, and backpacking. Testing
was mostly done in cool temperatures ranging from 15 to 40F.
Fit – Excellent,
as I have found with all Patagonia garments.
The garment’s body is extra long to cover the butt, and the sleeves are longer
too. Its slim cut makes it fit closer to my body, so it’s not bulky, and layers
well.
Features – The
hand pockets are nice and roomy, and zip for security. I like the stand-up
collar to provide some sun protection for my neck. The thumb loops are handy to
donn the jacket over a baselayer or other garment.
Wind-Resistance –
The tighter front fabric provides needed wind resistance so a cold wind does
not readily penetrate.
Breathability –
The frontside fabric does allow for some air exchange; it’s basically a
trade-off between wind resistance and insulation. The backside fabric is much
more breathable, but it is often mostly covered by a day pack or backpack.
Breathability is maximized in activities like running, bicycling, and
cross-country skiing where one does not normally carry a pack.
Performance – The
graph below tells a lot about the jackets performance while speed hiking an
undulating trail, carrying a daypack, in temperatures ranging from 25 to 30 F
and calm air. The test was done before sunrise to avoid sun warming. I recorded
the temperature and relative humidity inside the jacket with a Kestrel 4000,
located at mid-chest, at 10 second intervals.
Test data for Patagonia Nano-Air Hybrid Jacket |
Note that the jacket’s insulation maintained a fairly
constant internal temperature in the 65 to 70 F range, which is good. However,
humidity steadily built up inside the jacket as I hiked, and flattened out at
about 65%. That indicates that the jacket’s fabric breathability was not enough
to exhaust the moisture, allowing it to build up.
In terms of perceived comfort, it took about 45 minutes for
the humidity inside the jacket to build up to the point where the jacket felt
somewhat steamy inside and time to open the front zipper to increase
ventilation.
But that is only part of the comfort story, because the test
was done without any influence from the sun. I live in the Southwest
US , where we get a lot of sun, and the sun is warm even in the
winter. Thus the radiant heat from the sun has a big influence in jacket
comfort, even in cold air. There were many occasions when I simply had to take
the jacket off because it was too warm, when the air temperature was in the 30s
and 40s F.
Assessment
Although the Nano-Air Light Hybrid Jacket was often too warm
for me in the sunny Southwest, I found its sweet spot is cool, overcast, and
breezy conditions, which is what the jacket is designed for. When I had those
conditions, the jacket performed well for maintaining comfort over an extended
range. In locations where it is overcast or breezy much of the time, or the sun
is low, this jacket is capable of providing comfort over an extended range of
conditions, as claimed.
The more consistent conditions are – namely overcast, cool,
and breezy – the better this jacket will perform. Then all is good. The problem
I found is variability; when the sun comes out or the wind stops, I get too
hot. Opening the front zipper regulates comfort to some extent, but eventually
it is not enough. The Nano-Air definitely provides some extended comfort, but
the end result is usually the same – the jacket has to come off.
Bottom line, it’s a very attractive, great fitting, hi-tech
jacket that helps to provide extended comfort in cool, overcast, breezy
conditions, but in my situation those conditions don’t exist for very long. If
you exercise where those conditions are more typical, then this jacket is for
you. However, don’t expect a silver bullet, the breathability part is subtle.
Have you tried the rab vapour rise? Or even the rab vapour rise flex? I've been trying to find something for that 40-30 temp range
ReplyDelete